Suppose I have never played a game of chess. If I now make the claim that I've

Read another response by Richard Heck, Stephen Maitzen
Read another response about Language, Logic
Suppose I have never played a game of chess. If I now make the claim that I've won all the games of chess I've ever played, is that claim true, false, or undefined? A group of friends had an argument over this, and I figured that philosophers are deeply logical thinkers that can give us the answer and also to get a proper understanding of why the answer is what it is.

It would, of course, be equally true that you've lost every game of chess you've ever played. Bad news to go with the good.

Related Terms